News:

Guelph Treasure Heirs Respond to U.S. Brief that Argued Nazi Art Theft Was a Domestic Affair

1970
1945
Art Law Report 8 June 2020
By Nicholas O'Donnell

On behalf of my clients seeking restitution of the Guelph Treasure, or Welfenschatz, we filed today our supplemental brief with the U.S. Supreme Court in response to the Brief of the United States as Amicus Curiae that the Solicitor General’s office submitted on May 26, 2020. You can read today’s brief here, and read more about the particular problems with the Solicitor General’s filing here, most notably the contention that the Nazis’ property crimes against German Jews should be considered a “domestic” issue that doesn’t implicate international law under the Foreign Sovereign Immunities Act (FSIA). It was particularly distressing that the brief was signed not only by the U.S. Department of Justice, but also the State Department.

The filing follows an increasing pattern of disregard for bipartisan Congressional action, in this case the 2016 Holocaust Expropriated Art Recovery Act. Similarly, the 2017 Justice for Uncompensated Survivors Act that was enacted specifically to counter Poland’s and others’ hostility to restitution for Holocaust era assets has been ignored. The JUST Act required that the State Department issue a report on other countries’ restitution progress no later that November 9, 2019, yet no report has been issued. The State Department has a dedicated page on the JUST Act...which simply lists the law (Poland's embassy has its own rather self-serving version too). Something very curious is going on with restitution at the State Department, all the more heartbreaking given the 80 years of leadership on the topic by the United States.

We expect the Supreme Court to rule on whether it will hear the Welfenschatz case by the end of the month. If the Court grants the petition it would be argued next term. If the petition is denied, the case will return to the District Court in Washington, DC.


https://blog.sullivanlaw.com/artlawreport/guelph-treasure-heirs-respond-to-doj-brief-that-argued-nazi-art-theft-was-a-domestic-affair?utm_campaign=Art&utm_medium=email&_hsmi=89161950&_hsenc=p2ANqtz-8eWD22VTfxipNWXHHCS1g3wFcxIPNTb3zVWPyefGmHYAbQQdU4BaRt0j0
© website copyright Central Registry 2020